Top 30 Performance Creative Agencies in New York as of 2026

Finding a performance creative agency in New York that delivers real results is hard.

Still, 77% of in-house teams choose to partner with creative firms to enhance their brand's performance.

With over 200 creative agencies in NYC offering a wide range of services, including branding, digital marketing, and content creation, it's hard to know which agency will deliver the results you need.

In this article, you'll find:

• A curated list of the top 30 performance creative agencies in New York.
• The industries these agencies specialize in.
• Key services offered by each agency.
• Notable clients they have worked with.

Keep reading to discover the agency that aligns perfectly with your brand's needs.

P.S. Looking for broader digital expertise beyond performance creative? Check out our guide to the Top Digital Marketing Agencies in NYC to explore full-service partners that can scale every aspect of your growth.

TL;DR Comparison: Top 10 NYC Performance Creative Agencies

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick side-by-side look at the top NYC performance creative agencies:

Methodology Behind the 2026 Revision

The 2026 update builds upon the analytical structure and core assumptions presented in the original publication

To ensure accuracy and relevance, we applied the following methodological steps:

• Re-evaluated key arguments using the most recent industry data and peer-reviewed research (2024-early 2026).
• Cross-checked quantitative findings against updated statistical releases and market reports.
• Refined qualitative insights through comparative trend and scenario analysis.
• Validated conclusions against current macroeconomic and sector-specific indicators.

This approach preserves methodological continuity while enhancing analytical rigor, relevance, and forward-looking validity.

Benefits of Hiring a Top Performance Creative Agency in New York

Hiring a top performance creative agency in New York offers several distinct advantages over relying solely on an internal team or a generalist agency.

Access to Specialized Expertise

These agencies bring together sharp minds in design, strategy, analytics, and media buying.

That mix of skills means your campaigns not only look strong but are engineered to drive measurable impact.

In fact, businesses working with creative agencies report an average 23% increase in brand awareness within six months of engagement. 

In a city like New York, where niche markets and diverse audiences demand precision, this level of coordinated expertise becomes a true competitive advantage.

Scalability and flexibility

 Need to scale fast or shift gears mid-project? 

Agencies can ramp up or down without the hassle of hiring, training, or reshuffling your internal team. 

This adaptability is crucial, especially when 20% of agencies cite time constraints as a top challenge. 

For fast-paced NYC startups and enterprise brands alike, this flexibility supports momentum without the growing pains.

Cost Efficiency  

Building a full-time team comes with salaries, benefits, and overhead. 

With an agency, you pay for exactly what you need, no extras, no long-term commitments.

In fact, hiring a marketing agency can be nearly 50% more cost-effective than maintaining an in-house team. 

That’s especially valuable in New York, where operating costs and talent salaries run high.

Fresh Perspectives and Innovation

Outside teams bring fresh thinking. 

They stay on top of trends and tech, so your campaigns stay relevant, sharp, and ahead of the curve.

That matters because Nielsen determined that effective creative drives 86% of the sales lift in digital advertising, and the right ideas and execution directly impact performance.

In a trendsetting city like NYC, having a team that brings bold, outsider energy helps you stand out in crowded markets.

Advanced Tools and Technologies

Agencies invest in premium platforms and tools, giving you access to resources most internal teams don’t have on hand. 

And this shift is widespread, with AgencyAnalytics’ Marketing Agency Benchmarks Report finding that nearly 77% of marketing agencies have already adopted AI.

For example, agencies are increasingly using AI to increase creativity and build more innovative campaigns. 

With New York’s competitive marketing scene, access to these tools can give your brand a serious performance edge. 

According to Dustin Engel:

"Agencies, marketers and marketing technology companies that are already refining their business models by articulately weaving AI into their operations are poised for success. (...) The effortlessness of testing ideas, copy, creative, creating alternative strategies, or simply breaking through a creative block are game-changers. Inefficiency and workflow waste are everywhere." (Dustin Engel, co-founder and principal consultant of Elegant Disruption)

Efficient Project Turnaround 

With clear processes and a dedicated team, agencies keep things moving. 

You’ll often get faster results because they’re not juggling a million internal tasks.

That’s also why outsourcing is so common at the highest level. 

One industry ranking shows that 84% of in-house teams partner with external creative agencies to speed up execution and scale creative output more efficiently.

Next, let’s dive into the standout New York agencies turning creativity into measurable performance.

A Deep Dive into Each Top Performance Creative Agency in New York

Now that you know why you need to hire a good performance creative agency in New York, let’s see what your best options are: 

1. inBeat

Location: 90 Broad St, 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10004.

Rating: 4.9 Clutch and G2.

inBeat is a leading performance-driven creative agency based in New York, built around one simple belief: creativity should convert.

Our team specializes in transforming UGC, influencer content, and high-performing concepts into paid social assets engineered for scale. 

Every piece of creative we produce is designed to move the metrics that matter: ROAS, CPA, CTR, and CVR.

Our strategy, production, and media buying teams work as one unit to constantly test, learn, and optimize.
We identify what drives conversions, scale what performs, and cut what doesn’t, across Google Ads, Facebook, TikTok, Instagram, and other paid channels.

That mindset is reflected in our 4.9-star ratings on platforms like Clutch and G2, as well as in the scale at which we operate: millions in managed media spend and hundreds of new creative assets produced every month.

If you're wondering whether we’re the right partner, our case studies show exactly what we deliver:

• We helped NYC-based mobile app Greenpark cut CPI by 70%, increase daily installs 6x, and scale ad spend by 300%, while maintaining efficiency.
• For NYC Votes, we activated 10 local creators and launched TikTok-native performance content that generated 2.5M views and a 70% average view-through rate, effectively mobilizing young voters across New York City.

That’s the kind of performance partner your brand deserves.

Industries: Mobile Applications, CPG and DTC brands, Retail, eCommerce, Agencies, Fashion, Food.

Notable clients: New Balance, Deux par Deux, Linktree, Hopper, Nissan, Disney, Hurom.

Key services:

• Media Buying
• Social Media Advertising
• Programmatic Marketing
• UGC Creation
• TikTok and Instagram Marketing & Advertising
• Micro - Influencer and Nano-Influencer Marketing
• Paid Advertising
• Dark posting, Whitelisting
• Performance Branding
• Measurement, Attribution & Analytics

Reason to work with inBeat: You gain a performance-driven creative system built to reduce acquisition costs and scale efficiently, proven by 70% lower CPI, 6x install growth, and campaigns managing millions in media spend.

2. M+C Saatchi Performance

Location: 16 West 22nd Street, 9th Floor, New York, NY 10010.

Rating: 5.0 / 5.0 Gartner. 

M&C Saatchi Performance knows how to get brands growing with smart digital moves. Based in New York, they’re all about making your marketing plans work harder.

From search to social, programmatic to influencer marketing, even streaming platforms, they’ve got your media buying covered.

Their playbook is fully data-driven, with a strong grip on customer behavior and how to guide users through every stage of their journey.

In fact, companies that leverage customer behavior data outperform peers by 85% in sales growth and more than 25% in gross margin, according to McKinsey.

If you need help with mobile apps or affiliate marketing, they’re solid there too. 

Add in sharp analytics and a flexible strategy, and you’ve got a full-service digital marketing agency that moves fast and smart.

Industries: eCommerce, Fintech, Entertainment, Mobile Applications, Streaming Services, Fashion

Notable clients: Amazon, MPL, Rakuten, Asics.

Key services:

• Paid Search
• Paid Social
• Programmatic Advertising
• App Marketing
• App Store Optimization
• Affiliate Marketing
• Data Analytics & Tech
• Market Insights

Reason to work with M&C Saatchi Performance: Their approach to marketing is straight to the point: data first, results next. Every decision is grounded in numbers and audience insights.

3. DPDK

Location: 185 Wythe Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249.

Rating: 4.8 Birdeye.

DPDK landed in Brooklyn in 2017, bringing its creative energy from the Netherlands to the United States. 

And they've been shaking things up ever since.

From SEM to CRM and data analytics, they cover the full picture and deliver campaigns that feel fresh and focused.

DPDK’s team mixes creative design with serious tech skills, which means you get the best of both worlds.

If you care about customer engagement, campaign optimization, and smart strategy, you’ll feel right at home here.

In fact, are you familiar with Rosco Vision’s new product, DV6? Yes, DPDK was behind their go-to market campaign that led to 377% more leads with creatives like these:

While DPDK blends creative storytelling with digital strategy, inBeat Agency focuses on performance from the start. Our system is built to scale fast and deliver results you can track.

Industries: eCommerce, Technology, Consumer Goods, Healthcare, Finance, Fashion, Real Estate.

Notable clients: Nike, Firstleaf, HKliving.

Key services:

• Digital Strategy
• Branded Content Production
• Search Engine Marketing (SEM)
• Data and Analytics
• Personalization and CRM

Reason to work with DPDK: Their creative approach to marketing delivers big impact. If you want standout work that actually performs, DPDK brings the edge.

4. Mason Interactive

‍Location: 20 Jay Street, Suite 1115. Brooklyn, NY 11201.

Rating: 4.4 Birdeye.

Mason Interactive has been around since 2008, and they’ve got the track record to prove it.

Over $1 billion in managed ad spend? Yeah, they know what they’re doing.

They mix strategy, creative, and analytics to drive growth you can actually measure.

Their full-funnel setup covers everything: paid media, SEO, lifecycle marketing, and scroll-stopping creative.

They work with both up-and-coming startups and bigger names, always tailoring their marketing plans to fit the brand like a glove.

You’ll see the impact in better ROI, stronger brand presence, and smarter customer acquisition.

Plus, their team keeps the vibe open and collaborative, with transparent communication every step of the way.

Industries: eCommerce, Beauty, Fashion, Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG), Lifestyle, Education, B2B

Notable clients: AMAN Essentials, Alexis Bittar, Casio, AdAge.

Key services:

• Paid Media (Google, Facebook, Instagram, Amazon, YouTube, TikTok, Pinterest, Snapchat, Programmatic)
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Social Media Marketing
• Email and SMS Marketing
• Creative & Production

Reason to work with Mason Interactive: They’re a full-service agency with a clear focus, getting real results. From blog posts to big ad campaigns, everything is backed by valuable insights and a strategy that sticks.

5. Amsive

Location: 915 Broadway, Suite 501, New York, NY 10010.

Rating: 4.8 Clutch.

Amsive is a New York City agency that takes performance marketing seriously, but without the stiff vibe.

They dig deep into data to help brands win across channels. Think direct mail, digital media, SEO, content, creative design, and more.

What makes them different? Their Audience Science® model. It’s all about matching you with your ideal crowd, online or offline.

That means you’ll get real-world strategies powered by data-driven insights and grounded in how your audience actually behaves. And that’s great because 90% of companies see better results if they personalize their campaigns.

Anyway, Amsive are experts at bringing it all together, from digital campaigns to traditional advertising services, so your marketing plans feel unified and strong.

Industries: Healthcare, Financial, Insurance, Retail + Consumer Goods, Education, B2B, eCommerce, and more.

Notable clients: Fast Company, University of Tennessee, American Montessori Society.

Key services:

• Audience Science®
• Brand Strategy
• Media Planning
• Digital Media
• Programmatic Advertising
• Video + Streaming
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

Reason to work with Amsive: They’re a full-service digital marketing agency that blends smart targeting with creative execution. You’ll walk away with a digital marketing campaign that’s truly aligned with your goals.

6. Tinuiti

Location: 111 W 33rd St Suite 1510, New York, NY 10120.

Rating: 5.0 Clutch.

Tinuiti is a full-funnel performance agency that’s all about results, and they’re based right in New York.

They’ve got a tech edge too, thanks to their own platform, Bliss Point by Tinuiti. It helps you figure out exactly where your marketing dollars will go the furthest.

You can tap into their full-service agency model, from creative services and influencer marketing to CRO and email/SMS campaigns. And that’s great because influencer campaigns have an ROI of 520%!

Besides, Tinuiti are big on partnerships. Their team is obsessed with helping brands grow, and their client testimonials speak for themselves.

For example, they created a sharp Instacart strategy for Wild Planet that drove a 54% jump in new-to-brand sales and a 2-point market share boost!

Industries: Apparel, B2B, Beauty, Food & Beverage, Home Services.

Notable clients: Fivetran, Dickies, The Honest Company.

Key services:

• Commerce Media
• Streaming & Linear TV
• Paid Search & SEO
• Social Media Marketing
• Creative Services
• Conversion Rate Optimization
• Influencer Marketing

Reason to work with Tinuiti: This team blends smart tech with sharp strategy. They help you stretch every marketing dollar while keeping performance front and center.

7. Digital Drew SEM

Location: 110 E 28th St 10th Floor, New York, NY 10016.

Rating: 4.8 Clutch.

Digital Drew SEM Digital Drew SEM is a New York-based performance marketing agency focused on Google Ads (SEM), Meta advertising, and SEO. 

The team helps brands attract new customers while improving campaign ROI through structured testing and precise account management. 

With 230+ satisfied clients and 410 completed projects, they bring both scale and consistency to the table. 

Founder-led and tightly staffed, the agency stays close to every account, combining daily optimization with creative strategy across e-commerce, legal, tech, and service industries.

Industries: Business Services, eCommerce, Entertainment, Real Estate, Medical, Legal, Tech, and Services.

Notable clients: Pet Pro Supply Co., Cane & Austin, Tevah Media, New York Audio Academy.

Key services:

• Google Advertising
• Facebook & Instagram Advertising
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Social Media Marketing
• Email Marketing
• Website Design and Development

Reason to work with Digital Drew SEM: Their no-nonsense approach and transparent communication make them a solid partner if you want results, not jargon.

8. Quirk

Location: 67 35th St b522, Brooklyn, NY 11232.

Rating: 4.3 Trustburn.

Quirk Creative is a woman-owned, Brooklyn-based video advertising agency creating TV, OTT, social, and digital video campaigns built for brand response. 

Since it’s a boutique team, the process stays tight and collaborative, while still covering the full range from creative strategy to animatic testing and production. 

Quirk’s majority women-led team leans into direct response methodology, then pairs it with data-informed optimization to improve effectiveness and brand lift. 

On top of that, their work has earned Gold at the Muse Awards, plus additional festival wins, which says a lot about the quality behind the performance focus.

Industries: Food & Beverage, Beauty & Grooming, Apparel, Health & Wellness, Finance, B2B, Education, Home Goods.

Notable clients: Cirkul, Hungryroot, Chomps, Home Chef.

Key services:

• TV Commercial Production
• Streaming and Digital Video Ads
• Creative Strategy and Concept Development
• Multilingual Campaigns
• Live-Action and Animated Content

Reason to work with Quirk: Quirk keeps things nimble, creative, and on schedule. If you want top-tier content without the corporate drag, they’re a great fit.

9. Socium Media

Location: 251 W. 30th Street; Office 501 Floor 5; New York, NY 10001.

Rating: 4.9 Clutch.

Socium Media is a New York City performance marketing agency focused on paid search (SEM/PPC), paid social, and performance creative for midmarket and enterprise brands.

Since 2019, they’ve managed over $100 million in annual client ad spend, which already says a lot about trust and scale. 

Even better, results back it up: Clutch reviews mention 590% increases in orders for fashion clients, plus strong ROAS lifts across multiple platforms.

Their real edge is Socium Studios, a data-led creative process where assets get tested and refined for conversion, instead of being picked based on taste. 

And since they’re a certified Premier Agency Partner with Google, Meta, TikTok, and Pinterest, they combine serious platform access with performance accountability, especially for B2C and e-commerce teams.

Industries: eCommerce, Fashion, Beauty & Skincare, Automotive, Food & Beverage.

Notable clients: IGAP, Fine Linens, Topo Designs.

Key services:

• Performance Creative Strategy
• Creative Asset Development
• Iterative Testing and Optimization
• Competitor Analysis
• Creative Roadmapping

Reason to work with Socium Studios: Socium blends design services with campaign optimization. Your content looks good, performs better, and keeps getting smarter.

10. RepIndia

Rating: 4.5 Clutch.

RepIndia combines creative marketing, SEO, and paid media execution for brands aiming at visibility and conversions in New York’s competitive digital space. 

The agency brings serious volume to the table, with 500+ clients, 2,000+ completed projects, and 100+ industry awards backing its experience. 

Although headquartered internationally, the team applies structured campaign frameworks that translate well to NYC-focused audiences.

As a result, brands get coordinated execution across channels, supported by large-scale project experience and a track record recognized well beyond local peers.

Industries: eCommerce, Technology, Travel and Tourism, Medical, Retail, eCommerce.

Notable clients: Merino Group, Instax, JSW Steel.

Key services:

• Strategic Digital Advertising
• Audience-Centric Campaigns
• Innovative Content Creation
• Cost-Effective Video Production

Reason to work with RepIndia: RepIndia brings a creative spark and backs it up with solid strategy. Expect a collaborative approach that pushes your brand into fresh territory.

11. Collective World

Location: New York 99 Hudson Street, New York, NY 10013.

Collective World is a performance marketing agency out of NYC doing something different, they bring sustainability to the digital game.

They’re a B Corp-certified crew using green AdTech to help brands scale up without cranking up their carbon footprint.

You get the whole package: paid media, SEO, social, CX, CRO, analytics. And they do it all with partners that share their eco-friendly mindset.

One cool edge? Their use of digital twin tech. That means super-realistic product replicas that make your digital marketing campaign way more efficient. Here’s how they work:

So if you're into scaling your brand with purpose and precision, this full-service agency checks both boxes.

Industries: Automotive, Travel & Tourism, Food & Beverage, Technology, Entertainment, B2B.

Notable clients: Avis Budget Group, The Carbon Trust, Lela Inc, Carbon Trust.

Key services:

• Paid Media
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Customer Experience (CX)
• Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO)
• Social Media Marketing
• Distribution and Analytics

Reason to work with Collective World: They mix creative ideas with clean tech. It’s all about driving results while keeping your marketing footprint light.

12. Jane Creative

Location: 108 W 39th St #1200, New York, NY 10018.

Rating: 4.8/5.0 FeaturedCustomers.

Jane Creative is a NYC agency that cuts the fluff and focuses on what works. They’re built for direct-to-consumer brands that care about results, not filler.

Their digital marketing campaigns are simple and effective. No extra services you don’t need, only the stuff that drives traffic and conversions.

They’ll help you make social ads that feel real and get people to stop scrolling. And their email marketing game is on point.

They’ve got SEO and PPC advertising knowledge too, so your brand gets noticed by the right people at the right time.

If you're into smart moves and clean strategy, this one’s for you.

In fact, Jane Creative gave Essence Cosmetics a serious glow-up, boosting organic impressions by 61% and organic sessions by 85%!

Industries: Fashion, Health and Wellness, Fitness, Consumer Packaged Goods, Home and Lifestyle

Notable clients: Catrice Cosmetics, Splits59, Hair Club, Barry’s Bootcamp

Key services:

• Social Media Advertising (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Pinterest)
• Email Marketing (Promotional, Automated, Transactional)
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Pay-Per-Click Advertising (Google, Bing, YouTube)
• Website Design and Development

Reason to work with Jane Creative: It’s a straight-shooting agency that delivers. Their approach to marketing is lean, efficient, and laser-focused on growth.

13. Socialfly NY

Location: 231 W 29th St #702, New York, NY 10001.

Rating: 4.5 Clutch.

Socialfly brings real energy to the digital space. This New York-based digital marketing agency is woman-led, data-smart, and full of fresh ideas.

They’re all about helping brands connect through social media, creative storytelling, and influencer campaigns that actually stick.

They create content that feels native to each platform, so your brand’s voice fits right in wherever your audience is hanging out, which is important because native ads are viewed 53% more than traditional display ads and can increase purchase intent by 18%.

You’ll also get campaigns that are cohesive, goal-driven, and made to build long-term customer engagement.

If you’re looking to tap into authentic voices and expand reach through influencer marketing, this team has the network to make it happen.

Industries: Fashion, Beauty and Skincare, Health and Wellness, Hospitality, Food and Beverage, eCommerce.

Notable clients: Apartment List, Hudson Yards New York, The Madison Square Garden Company.

Key services:

• Social Media Management
• Influencer Marketing
• Creative Content Production
• Paid Media Strategy
• SEO and Digital Strategy

Reason to work with: They mix strong strategy with creative content and a collaborative approach. Plus, their female-led team brings a fresh take to every project.

14. Voy Media

Location: 225-16 95th Ave, Bellerose, NY 11001.

Rating: 4.3 Trustpilot.

Voy Media is a New York–based performance advertising and creative studio focused on Facebook and Instagram ads, retargeting, and high-volume creative production for e-commerce and direct-to-consumer brands. 

The agency states it has generated $183M in revenue and produces 12,721 creative assets per month, which supports fast testing cycles and frequent iteration across paid campaigns.

In addition, Voy Media claims 92% of clients double revenue within the first year of working together. 

Because of this mix of ad management and creative execution, client stories often describe a path from six-figure to eight-figure monthly sales, driven by structured testing, optimization, and constant refresh of ad creatives.

Industries: eCommerce, Startups, Education, Consumer Goods, LinkedIn, Health and Wellness.

Notable clients: Paw.com, Lacoste, Big Life Journal, Trinity Hills Co.

Key services:

• Facebook & Instagram Advertising
• Retargeting Campaigns
• Creative Studio (Video Production, Graphic Design, Copywriting)
• Custom Audience Development
• Dynamic Product Ads
• One-on-One Strategy Consultations

Reason to work with Voy Media: A high-output creative system producing 12,721 assets per month, backed by $183M generated and 92% of clients doubling revenue in year 1.

15. QNY Creative

Location: 515 Madison Ave 35 Floor, New York, NY 10022.

Rating: 5.0 rating from 5 reviews on Clutch.

QNY Creative is a Manhattan-based interdisciplinary agency focused on branding, packaging design, and performance marketing for lifestyle, CPG, and hospitality brands.

The firm has earned 50+ industry awards across digital, design, web, and social campaigns, which highlights both creative depth and execution range. 

Their portfolio also includes recognizable names such as National Geographic and a New York Jets activation that reached 21 million+ people, showing real audience scale.

Clients move from packaging and visual systems straight into digital activation with a consistent story and coordinated campaign rollout.

Industries: Hospitality, Food & Beverage, Beauty & Fashion, Lifestyle, CPG.

Notable clients: Venchi, Keebler, Eataly, Citterio.

Key services:

• Brand Development and Packaging Design
• Web Design and Development
• Content Strategy and Production
• Search Engine Marketing and Media Buying
• Social Media Management

Reason to work with QNY Creative: They bring style, structure, and strategy. If you want your brand to look great and perform even better, they’re a solid pick.

16. Havas New York

Location: 200 Hudson St, New York, NY 10013.

Rating: 4.4 Birdeye.

Havas New York is the North American flagship of the global Havas Creative network, bringing together brand strategy, advertising, and content creation from a central Manhattan hub. 

The agency runs with multidisciplinary teams, so projects move smoothly from concept to production across traditional and digital formats. 

It also carries strong industry recognition, including Ad Age Best Places to Work in 2019 and 2021, plus Drum Network Agency of the Year awards.

Campaigns like the Ali Forney Center’s “The Issue Within the Issue” show how Havas builds storytelling around real audience insight, while launches for Mike’s Amazing and Brooklyn Film Festival highlight their range across multimedia. 

Brands get creative that feels culturally tuned, while still being built with structure and strategy behind every detail.

Industries: Consumer Goods, Technology, Healthcare, Hospitality, Financial Services.

Notable clients: Silk, The Harris Project, Wyndham Hotels & Resorts, The Harris Project.

Key services:

• Creative Advertising
• Media Planning and Buying
• Brand Strategy
• Digital Marketing
• Public Relations

Reason to work with Havas New York: They mix the depth of a global network with the speed and care of a boutique team, always keeping your business objectives front and center.

17. Tug Agency

Location: 214 W 29th St New York, NY 10001.

Tug Agency is a digital agency that takes a performance-first approach, with boots on the ground in New York City and beyond.

They’ve been at it since 2006, blending local market smarts with international reach.

Their work is grounded in a clear strategy: Discovery, Strategy, Build & Launch, and Test, Learn & Optimize. This process is how they keep their advertising campaigns sharp.

Tug Labs adds even more value with custom-built AI tools that solve real client problems. For example, Tug boosted END's average basket size by 34% with a 126% ROAS in just 4 weeks!.

They’re the type of advertising agency that focuses on data, creativity, and strong digital channels to reach potential customers.

Industries: eCommerce, Healthcare, Financial Services, Hospitality, Retail

Notable clients: Merlin, Milk & More, Heinemann, Zipcar

Key services:

• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Pay-Per-Click (PPC) Advertising
• Content Marketing
• Social Media Management
• Data and Digital Strategy

Reason to work with Tug: Tug creates a collaborative environment that fuels smart thinking and successful campaigns, backed by data and a deep understanding of every client’s needs.

18. Hawke Media

Location: 675 Hudson St #3S, New York, NY 10014.

Rating: 4.9 Birdeye.

Hawke Media is a performance-focused advertising agency based in LA with a strong New York presence.

Since 2014, they’ve been helping brands grow by offering CMO-level insights through flexible, month-to-month services.

You only pay for what you need, and they bring in top-tier creative expertise across every touchpoint.

With their in-house analytics platform, Hawke AI, they keep your marketing goals tracked and on target with real-time data.

This setup makes them a reliable partner for businesses ready to move fast.

Industries: eCommerce, Fashion, Beauty, Technology, Consumer Goods, Food & Beverage

Notable clients: Verizon, Red Bull, Crocs, Barstool Sports

Key services:

• Affiliate Marketing
• Amazon Services
• Branding & Production
• Content Creation
• Lifecycle Marketing
• Media Buying

Reason to work with Hawke Media: Hawke Media offers flexibility, clear ROI, and a creative team that knows how to turn ideas into successful campaigns.

19. DAC Group

Rating: 4.7/5.0 FeaturedCustomers.

DAC Group is a full-funnel digital performance agency with a New York presence, combining paid media, SEO, and local presence management for enterprise and multilocation brands.

Founded in 1972, the company brings long-standing expertise while operating with modern systems supported by AI-enhanced platforms like IRIS. 

Their approach helps large brands stay consistent at scale while still feeling relevant in individual neighborhoods.

And the tech stack takes it further.

Proprietary tools such as Guardrail streamline content workflows for large networks, while TotalSERP creates integrated search visibility across channels. 

Industries: Retail, Healthcare, Financial Services, Hospitality, Automotive, Retail, CPG, Fashion

Notable clients: StorageMart,  La Maison Simons, MTY Group

Key services:

• Paid Media (Digital and Traditional)
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO and Local SEO)
• Content Strategy and Creation
• Local Presence Management
• Data Science and Analytics

Reason to work with DAC Group: Their creative expertise and custom platforms help you stay competitive across all digital channels, while keeping campaigns focused and effective.

20. The Charles Group

Location: 200 Broadway, Suite 307, New York, NY 10038.

Rating: 5.0 Clutch.

The Charles Group is a full-service creative and digital experience studio headquartered in New York City, with additional offices in Chicago and London.

Founded in 2011 by sibling leaders, the agency combines brand strategy, content creation, and technology + media execution for lifestyle, luxury, fashion, and hospitality brands. 

Their client list includes Birkenstock, Aveda, and Marriott Bonvoy, and their work has also earned Webby Award recognition.

This works especially well for heritage brands that need modern digital performance, as well as fast-scaling names that need structure without losing style.

Industries: Lifestyle, Luxury, Fashion, Beauty.

Notable clients: HP, Ferrari, Birkenstock, Aveda, Marriott Bonvoy.

Key services:

• Brand Strategy & Consulting
• Content Creation & Production
• Visual Design & User Experience
• Digital Marketing & Media Buying
• Web Development & E-commerce Solutions

Reason to work with The Charles Group: A Webby-recognized studio known for merging UX, content, and media into cohesive experiences for premium global brands.

21. Acronym

Location: 350 5th Ave #6520, New York, NY 10118.

Acronym has been a fixture in the New York marketing scene since 1995.

Headquartered in the Empire State Building, this performance marketing agency knows how to run digital campaigns that deliver.

They specialize in both paid and organic media, search optimization, eCommerce, and analytics, crucial areas given that over 53% of all website traffic comes from organic search.

And it’s all powered by their patented tech platform.

With campaigns running in over 70 countries and services offered in multiple languages, they bring serious global reach to the table.

This digital agency backs its work with a deep understanding of multiple industries, using smart tools to target potential customers and drive measurable growth.

Industries: Technology, Hospitality, Finance, Healthcare, Retail, B2B.

Notable clients: SAP, PayPal, Jegs, Wharton.

Key services:

• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Pay-Per-Click (PPC) Advertising
• Social Media Marketing
• eCommerce Marketing
• Digital Analytics

Reason to work with Acronym: Their global scale, long-standing industry expertise, and creative production tools make them a reliable partner for digital marketing services that get results.

22. Stramasa

Rating: 5.0 Clutch.

Stramasa is a digital marketing agency in New York with a clear focus on B2B growth.

They bring a strategic approach to everything they do: SEO, PPC, content, and a strong social media strategy included.

This agency takes a personalized route, building campaigns based on your actual business needs and data.

Their dedicated team stays on top of trends and tech, bringing innovative strategies that help you stay ahead of the curve.

Everything they do is about helping you reach more potential customers and turn attention into action.

Stramasa creates strong B2B strategies just like inBeat. We, however, lead with sharp creative and a lean, fast-moving team. 

Our influencer engine and rapid content testing help brands connect and convert at scale.

Industries: Healthcare, Technology & SaaS, Consumer Electronics, Hospitality, Automotive, Manufacturing.

Notable clients: Roche, Nestle, IBM, IQVIA.

Key services:

• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Pay-Per-Click (PPC) Advertising
• Content Marketing
• Social Media Management
• Email Marketing

Reason to work with Stramasa: They combine a data-first mindset with sharp industry expertise, creating digital marketing services that feel custom-built for measurable growth.

23. Impression Digital

Location: 160 Varick St, New York, NY 10013.

Rating: 4.9 Clutch.

Impression is a New York-based performance agency with a creative team of over 120 pros working across digital campaigns from retail to luxury brands.

They deliver results with a mix of strategy, analytics, and creative assets tailored for your goals.

Their team blends experimentation with real data to build smart, evolving campaigns that make an impact.

From SEO and digital PR to paid media and CRO, they build every piece around clear business objectives.

They’ve built up trust with big-name brands and deliver performance that proves it. Here’s just one example:

Impression helped a major UK Muslim charity hit 18x ROAS, 500% over target, during Ramadan, boosting revenue 233% year over year!

Industries: Retail, Travel, Finance, SaaS, Home Improvement, Fashion, Luxury & Beauty.

Notable clients: NORSE, Clarins, Specsavers.

Key services:

• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Pay-Per-Click (PPC) Advertising
• Digital PR & Content Marketing
• Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO)
• Marketing Automation
• Creative Campaign Development

Reason to work with Impression: Impression brings creative production together with evidence-based execution, helping you grow with smarter digital marketing services.

24. Gupta Media

Location: 41 E 11th St. New York, NY 10003.

Rating: 4.8/5.0 Gupta Media.

Gupta Media is a performance-focused marketing agency with a New York office, combining paid media, analytics, and in-house creative studio capabilities for brands like Amazon and the Cleveland Cavaliers. 

With 20+ years in performance marketing, the team manages billions of impressions annually through its proprietary analytics engine, ReportSE. 

This platform delivers real-time insights that directly inform campaign decisions and budget allocation across accounts.

ReportSE connects data streams across search, social, CTV, and OOH, giving brands a clear operational view at scale. 

Recognition as one of the Boston Globe’s Top Places to Work 2025 further reflects the strength of the organization behind the campaigns.

Industries: Entertainment, Retail, Technology, Healthcare, Finance, B2B.

Notable clients: CAVS, IMDbPro, Oak View Group, Mythical.

Key services:

• Paid Media Planning & Buying
• Creative Strategy & Development
• Data Analytics & Reporting
• Custom Technology Solutions
• Social Media Marketing

Reason to work with Gupta Media: Their mix of media, tech, and creative production helps brands connect with potential customers while keeping growth measurable and scalable.

25. Front Row

Location: 14 Pennsylvania Plaza Suite 2020, New York, NY 10122.

Front Row is a New York–based e-commerce and marketing agency connecting Amazon marketplace strategy, retail media, brand positioning, and creative content for beauty, wellness, and CPG brands. 

With 500+ global full-time employees and operations across 30+ marketplaces and countries, the team operates with serious scale. 

Their proprietary Catapult business-intelligence platform translates complex commerce data into structured strategic action across regions.

But Scale only matters when it performs.

So, Catapult powers real-time optimization and deep marketplace intelligence, giving brands tighter control over visibility and sales performance.

For example, Microbiome Labs reclaimed $2.8M in revenue, expanded Buy Box ownership to 94%, and increased Amazon sales by 162% through Front Row’s integrated approach.

Industries: Beauty, Health & Wellness, Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG), Fashion, Lifestyle

Notable clients: Cinema Secrets, OUAI, Spendit, Microbiome Labs.

Key services:

• Digital Marketing
• eCommerce Management
• Content Creation
• Business Intelligence
• Marketplace Partnership

Reason to work with Front Row: A 500+ person global team powered by the Catapult intelligence platform delivering results like 162% Amazon sales lifts and 94% Buy Box ownership.

26. Avenue Z

Location: 156 5th Avenue. New York, NY 10010.

Rating: 4.7 Clutch.

Avenue Z is a New York-based performance media and creative agency combining performance creative, paid social, and paid search with AI-enhanced optimization and strategic PR. 

The team runs iterative creative testing frameworks that connect content with platform data, creating tighter feedback loops across campaigns. 

For brands like TWICE, this approach delivered a 174% revenue increase while lowering CPA, showing clear financial impact tied directly to execution.

Recognized for innovation in AI Search Optimization and performance tech, Avenue Z structures advanced analytics and rapid experiment cycles into daily workflows. 

This system improves conversion rates and strengthens attribution clarity across TikTok, Meta, and Google.

Industries: Fintech and Finance, Venture Capital & Private Equity, DTC & Luxury, Health, Web3, Crypto, Blockchain, B2B, Public Affairs.

Notable clients: Dave, e2open, April.

Key services:

• Strategic Communications
• PR / Media Relations
• AI Optimization
• Content & Creative
• Paid Media
• Performance Creative
• Influencer Marketing Integration

Reason to work with Avenue Z: An AI-driven performance agency delivering results like a 174% revenue increase through iterative creative testing and advanced attribution systems.

27. Razorfish

Location: 375 Hudson St Floor 4, New York, NY 10014.

Rating: 4.7/5.0 FeaturedCustomers.

Razorfish is a New York-based digital transformation and marketing agency with 30+ years of experience building brand experiences, media strategy, and CRM and loyalty programs. 

The agency has earned recognition such as Best Digital Agency at the 2022 VIP Awards, along with multiple workplace accolades that reflect both creative quality and operational strength.

Through its Beta Lab, Razorfish is developing AI-powered offerings that help brands scale content production and create conversational experiences using custom generative AI tools.

This blend of long-term expertise and modern experimentation makes the agency a strong partner for brands that want strategy, creative, and technology working in one system.

Industries: Consumer Goods, Retail, Finance, Healthcare, Real Estate, Beauty

Notable clients: Trojan, Audacious Real Estate, Dove

Key services:

• Integrated Brand Experience
• Consumer & Content Experience
• Media Experience
• Retail & Commerce Experience
• CRM & Loyalty Experience

Reason to work with Razorfish: A 30+ year NYC agency recognized as Best Digital Agency (2022 VIP Awards) and backed by Beta Lab AI tools for scalable content and conversational experiences.

28. SINE Digital

Location: 1501 Broadway, Suite 1614, Manhattan, NY 10036.

Rating: 4.7/5.0 FeaturedCustomers. 

SINE Digital is a performance marketing agency with teams in New York and London, built around live entertainment, sports, and ticketed experiences. 

Founded in 2017, SINE has supported 400+ live events and worked with brands and productions such as Tottenham Hotspur and Wicked.

The team combines creative and media execution with AI-backed audience insights.

Because of this setup, SINE runs campaigns using Media Mix Modelling, AI analytics, and real-time dashboards, so targeting, spend allocation, and channel performance stay aligned throughout the full campaign cycle.

Industries: Live Entertainment, Sports, Fashion, Lifestyle, eCommerce, Charities.

Notable clients: Percival, sfp, Punchdrunk, Yamaha, Tottenham Hotspur, Wicked.

Key services:

• Paid Media & Social Advertising
• Programmatic Advertising
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Media Mix Modeling
• AI-Driven Creative Insights

Reason to work with SINE Digital: A 2017-founded agency supporting 400+ live events with AI analytics and Media Mix Modelling built specifically for ticketed experiences.

29. NoGood

Location: 491 Broadway, New York, NY 10012.

Rating: 5.0 Clutch.

NoGood is a New York-based performance branding and marketing agency combining paid media, SEO, AEO, and structured experimentation for startups, scaleups, and Fortune 500 brands. 

Their model centers on custom “growth squads” that bring together strategists, creatives, and data scientists within one unit. 

This setup has delivered strong outcomes, including 65% of clients doubling revenue within 6 months and 88% client retention across engagements.

The internal structure drives the momentum.

NoGood connects creative insights directly with media decisions, creating fast feedback cycles that refine audience targeting and conversion performance. 

With this system, campaigns evolve continuously while staying aligned across brand positioning and acquisition strategy.

Industries: Software as a Service (SaaS), Healthcare, Fintech, B2B, Consumer Products, Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Notable clients: Inflection AI, JVN Hair, Steelseries

Key services:

• Performance Branding
• Paid Social Advertising
• Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
• Content Marketing
• Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO)
• Lifecycle Marketing

Reason to work with NoGood: A squad-based performance team achieving results like 65% of clients doubling revenue in 6 months and maintaining 88% retention.

30. Character

Location: 53 Bridge St #101, Brooklyn, NY 11201.

Character is a NYC performance white-listing shop built for DTC brands scaling past $100K/month in digital spend. 

They combine paid social with publisher-style advertorial creative, plus an owned creator network that gives campaigns more authenticity and reach. 

Character leans into real-world insights and community amplification, so ads feel native instead of forced. 

That approach has already reached 10 million potential customers and generated $50 million in new revenue, while their collaborations consistently highlight brand personality across different audience segments.

Industries: eCommerce, Direct-to-Consumer (DTC), Retail, Consumer Goods, Technology

Notable clients: Milk Bar, Proven, Nearby.

Key services:

• Performance Branding
• Creative Content Production
• Paid Media Strategy
• Media Buying and Distribution
• Customer Acquisition Optimization

Reason to work with Character: A white-listing specialist for $100K/month+ DTC spenders, backed by an owned creator network and $50 million in new revenue driven.

Key Factors in Choosing a Performance Creative Agency in New York

Creative quality is paramount in advertising effectiveness; according to Nielsen, 47% of a campaign's contribution to sales is attributable to the creative itself.

Besides that obvious quality, consider the following key factors when selecting a performance creative agency in New York:

Look for creative teams that understand ad platform algorithms

A great performance creative agency knows how platforms like Meta, TikTok, and YouTube reward specific formats, hooks, and user flows. 

Ask if they optimize for metrics like thumbstop rate, hold rate, or scroll depth, and if they design with machine learning inputs in mind, not just brand aesthetics.

Agencies that consistently build concepts capable of crossing a 30%+ thumbstop ratio demonstrate they can produce the kind of strong hooks UGC-style ads.

Ask about their creative testing frameworks and iteration cycles

High-velocity teams often aim to generate 20+ new concepts per month, which tells you how seriously they treat ongoing experimentation and the fight against fatigue. 

Do they version ads for different audience segments? 

How often do they refresh creatives to prevent fatigue?

Ask how they identify winning ads and scale them, and what happens when performance drops.

Make sure they integrate with your media buying team or agency

Creative and media should never work in silos.

When predictive creative analysis alone can lift campaign sales by around 40%, it only works if the creative team is plugged directly into the same performance data your media buyers use.

Look for agencies that work closely with whoever’s running your ads, in-house or external, to interpret performance, tweak copy, and adjust creative hooks in real time. 

Bonus points if they sit in on weekly performance reviews.

Check what creative analytics and insights they provide

Ask to see how they report on creative performance. 

The difference between surface-level reporting and real creative insight is not small, since brands that apply strong creative best practices can drive up to 7.4x higher short-term sales.

Do they deliver insights like “hook A beat hook B by 42% in scroll-stop rate” or just general impressions and clicks? 

You want a team that treats creative like a performance lever, not a deliverable.

Evaluate their agility and speed of production

New York agencies often serve fast-paced startups and growth teams, so your agency should match that energy. 

With nearly 90% of companies now offshoring creative production to scale resources and speed content delivery, the bar for fast, high-volume output is higher than ever. 

That’s why you should ask about typical turnaround times, revision processes, and how they handle urgent needs. 

Do they have in-house editing or on-call producers, or will every change take 10 days and 3 meetings?

Gauge their experience with brands at your stage and spend level

An agency that crushes for $500K/month DTC brands might not be ideal for a B2B SaaS company with longer sales cycles. 

McKinsey estimates that 15-20% of marketing spend can be recaptured through stronger ROI practices. 

So you want a team that already knows how to unlock those gains for companies operating at your maturity and spend tier

Ask about their client mix, creative testing budgets, and whether they’ve worked with brands at your exact growth stage, pre-product market fit, scaling, or enterprise expansion.

Performance Creative Agency Checklist

This checklist helps evaluate whether a creative agency is equipped to produce and scale performance-driven ads.

Typical Pricing for Performance Creative Agencies in NYC

NYC performance creative agencies usually price either on a monthly retainer or per project.

Based on Clutch benchmarks, digital marketing retainers commonly range from $5,000 to $50,000/month, and many services (including PPC and social) are often billed at $100-$149/hour. 

If video production is included, the average video project cost is around $42,280 (though many projects come in under $10,000), with production rates also commonly at $100-$149/hour. 

For faster testing, UGC-style videos usually cost roughly $150-$300+ per asset.

Wrapping Up

Choosing from the top 30 performance creative agencies in New York doesn’t have to be a headache.

You’ve now got the key info to help you make a move that fits your goals.

These agencies bring serious creative power, deep expertise, and the kind of flexibility that’s tough to build in-house.

Each one offers something unique, but inBeat stands out as the top choice for brands that want fast, scalable, high-performing content.

Look at what you really need, map it to your goals, and you’ll land on the right partner in no time.

P.S. If you’re also exploring partners for broader social strategy, don’t miss our guide to the Top Social Media Agencies in New York City. It’s a great next step before you decide.

FAQ

What are performance marketing agencies?

Performance marketing agencies focus on driving measurable results like clicks, conversions, and revenue. Everything they do is tracked and optimized to hit specific goals.

What are performance creatives?

Performance creatives are visual and written assets (like ads, videos, and UGC) designed to drive action. They're tested, tweaked, and backed by data to make sure they convert.

How much does performance marketing cost?

Costs can vary a lot depending on your goals, channels, and how much creative you need. Some agencies charge flat fees or retainers, while others work on a performance-based model.

Why is inBeat different from traditional creative agencies?

inBeat Agency builds content that's made to perform. Instead of long timelines and generic branding work, they use real-time data and rapid testing to create scalable content that actually moves the needle.

Does inBeat work well for fast-growing brands?

Yes. inBeat is perfect for growth-focused brands that need a constant stream of high-performing creative. Their in-house production and influencer systems help scale quickly without losing quality.

Is inBeat a good fit if I already have an internal team?

Absolutely. inBeat works as an extension of your existing team, bringing in creative firepower, performance strategy, and testing frameworks that plug right in and deliver results.